Archive for the ‘Comparative Economics’ Category

MR hearts JMK

January 17, 2007

Hugo Chavez calls Jesus the “greatest socialist in history.” Ok. We can solve this in one paragraph.

Jesus taught a moral philosophy; Socialism is an economic order. One’s philosophy exists independently of the economy. Jesus advocated non violence and the voluntary acceptance of God. Socialism can only exist when it is forced upon the masses, this violates non violence and voluntary acceptance. If Jesus was a socialist, Rothbard was a Keynesian.

Culture and Economics

January 17, 2007

People on both sides of the Atlantic think they can judge the economic systems of their countries by looking at cold facts and statistics such as the unemployment rate, the poverty rate, gdp per capita and so on. While this certainly has some merits, it fails to capture the essence of the systems observed; that is, the people living in those systems.

When you lay out a set of incentives, over time human behavior adjusts in an optimal way to these incentives. In a democratic system this creates a feedback loop. For example; in America people for the most part have to rely on their own labor to live a comfortable life. This has shaped a work ethic and a respect for wealth. In Europe, a welfare system was installed when people still had this work ethic. The next generation, ‘freed’ from cultural leftovers to work hard and not take advantage of the welfare system adjusted in an optimal way to this system. They try to get away with working as little as possible and taking as much advantage of the state as possible.

The tragedy here is that this also takes away a certain dependence on your fellow humans and a realisation that your all in the same boat, trying to survive by working. Instead you start to regard each other with suspicion, wondering if your neighbor is living of your tax dollars. If this neighbor is a recent immigrant from Morocco and doesnt speak your language because he doesn’t have to to survive this suspicion turns into xenophobia.

And here lies the danger, because in the feedback loop people go back to vote, and they start to vote nationalist and socialist, a logical outcome of a welfare society with high immigration. They turn inwards, and become statist. This is Western Europe in the present.

Statistics don’t tell the whole story in economics. It’s the interplay of political systems and institutions, and purposeful behavior.